Wow! The FILET MIGNON* was perfectly cooked. Juicy, flavorful, and buttery steak that just melts in your mouth. The loaded potatoes were amazing and Mac n cheese didnt miss. My man loved the TOM'S SOLE, perfectly cooked flakey fish with a delicious parmesan crust and sauce. I rarely review delivery food but 54th street did THAT GOOD!
T
Taylor M
5 contributions
31/7/24
• DoorDash order
Food was delicious! I will only eat spear cut FRIED PICKLES from 54th St & no where else - always top tier. First time trying the CRAB CAKES & they did not disappoint. The Mac was daddying - Good Soup *slurps soup*
A
Adam H
1 contributions
17/5/23
• DoorDash order
Ordered when they opened. Fries are soggy and undercooked. Two cherry limeades cost $11.10 before tax is 80% ice. Gringo dip is watery and flavorless. Sad to see one of my favorite places go downhill
A
Amanda D
3 contributions
1/3/25
• DoorDash order
This cheesecake is LEGITIMATELY better than cheesecake factory. I always get and extra strawberry puree sauce,.. Easily the best cheesecake I've ever had!
S
Susan H
2 contributions
25/10/23
• DoorDash order
Our meal was amazing. The Cajun Chicken Philly was appealing to the eye, and my husband said it was very satisfying. The burger was delicious, and the well-done fries were scrumptious. I hope they never stop offering those fries. The coleslaw is surprisingly sweet with the apples in it. We have ordered this exact meal many times, and it has always been consistent in taste and appearance. Fantastic restaurant, great service.
