Black Sheep Bagels
4.8(200+ ratings)•
DashPass•
American Traditional-Italian•
Store Info
DashPass
4.8(200+ ratings)•
$$•American Traditional-Italian
Full Menu
6:30 am–2:40 pmFeatured Items
USD 0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Reviews200+ ratings • 10+ public reviews
4.8
of 5 stars
S
Samantha H
2 contributions6/12/24
• DoorDash reviewBlack Sheep is hands down the BEST bagel shop on Long Island. The bagels are always soft and fresh and I love the variety of flavors, especially ones I never thought of! Cinnamon buns are hot and amazing! on top of the amazing food, the staff are always nice and welcoming. The owner Chris and his wife are always willing to help and are super friendly. Great job, Black Sheep!
M
Matt C
Emerging Expert • 11 contributions10/2/25
• DoorDash orderThe Coheed Cubano is a must! Juicy shreds of pork mix perfectly with what can only be fresh house made pickles, I'd imagine... but the bread is what makes it! This is a new favorite amongst so many on Black Sheep's boards - you can't miss, but definitely worth trying their Cuban! Add BACON for an extra crisp bite (I know what Cuban sandwich fans would say, but still)!
V
Valerie V
Emerging Expert • 9 contributions15/1/24
• DoorDash reviewI know I reviewed this amazing bagel shop after I initially moved here and tried them but I just can't get over how good everything is. Nothing has disappointed me yet. I get breakfast from here @ once a week and I just love them. I have ordered and enjoyed at least 4 of the different omelets and a couple of the egg & cheese sandwiches. My egg & cheese on the jalapeño cheddar bagel with avocado and hash brown added to it this morning prompted another review, I am seriously in love. If I didn't usually get food from you on the way home from my overnight shift with my dogs in the car I would pop in to tell you how awesome you are, instead of door dashing it. In LOVE people, try them.
R
Richelle C
31 contributions10/9/24
• DoorDash orderThere are a few sandwich shops in South Hampton but not like black sheep. every time I ask someone to make me The Aquebogue it never tastes like this one. The chicken cutlets are delicious, the tomatoes are definitely local, the lettuce I take off, the mozzarella cheese is so good & the BBQ sauce is the finishing touch to this great sandwich.
C
Cece J
7 contributions4/4/24
• DoorDash orderEverything is always perfect and delicious! I love that they make the Iced Coffee with coffee ice cubes so it never gets watered down.
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Smoked Salmon and Cream Cheese
Thin sliced smoked salmon on a bagel with cream cheese
Bagels
Flats
Whole Wheat Flats
Cream Cheese & Butter
select between 1/4lb 1/2b full lb.
Breakfast Sandwiches
Omelette
3 eggs, hash brown, toast.
Parfaits
Salads
On a sandwich / by the pound
Cold Cuts by the pound
All boars head meats.
Specialty Sandwiches
On a hero or flat for additional charge.
Acai Bowl
Gluten free, dairy free, vegan friendly. 100% usda certified organic. No fillers, juice or powders.
Paninis
Chips
All 2oz bags. All Hals Brand.