This was pretty much exactly what I wanted. I was sick of the same pizza from papa hut or domino johns or whatever, and tired of the generic pies that taste like every ingredient came fresh off the American Food Services truck and out of a white box with black letters saying "Pizza sauce" on it like they serve at the smaller chain stores. I wanted a pie like my parents would get on Friday nights as a kid. An almost dirty, floppy pie from some place with a family name like Demarco's or Frank's that had that authentic pizza place feel to it. This svelte chewy crust and slightly greasy pepperoni and cheese pie (16 in of course) really hit the spot in the way that very few other places do. I will be ordering again.
R
Richard S
1 contributions
28/1/25
• DoorDash order
2$ per topping, added black olives and there was a total of like 15 on the whole pizza. Barely any sauce for the pizza either, just generally felt like I was eating a cheap pizza. Would've rather had a frozen pizza from Walmart instead of paying 25 bucks for something like this again.
R
Rachael L
3 contributions
26/1/25
• DoorDash order
The pizza is VERY VERY GOOD! I grew up in PA and our pizza is something else!! I had yet to find a pizza place down here that had anything close...until I found Blue Pizza! The second I opened the box, I knew it was going to be delicious! The only bummer is that we had to warm it up by the time it got here..but that's not their fault. also got the Fried Mushrooms mushrooms. They're also really yummy!
S
Sabrina P
Emerging Expert • 15 contributions
5/1/24
• DoorDash order
The Mozzarella Sticks were hot, fresh, and delicious. They tasted seasoned but not salty. The marinara sauce also has great flavor. The Andrew Miller 8in pizza was also delicious! Everything was so fresh and perfect! I favorited this store for future ordering.
C
Catherine S
5 contributions
29/4/22
• DoorDash order
This pizza is one of the best, if not the best, in Columbia. The crust is delicious, not too thick, not too thin. The ingredients are fresh and the marinara is great! We love the NJ pizza and the cinnamon Italian donuts. Highly recommend this restaurant!
