I got the Build Your Own 12" with half pepperoni and half meatball, well done. The bread was nice and thick; they use mini pepperoni which is always a plus. The Twice-Baked Wings were a good size, tossed in hot buffalo sauce with a side of ranch. My pickup order experience was pleasant enough that I will be back to try their signature square butter crust.
R
Rod N
3 contributions
15/4/25
• DoorDash order
5 stars
I tried Butter Crust Pizza for the first time and it did not disappoint! I ordered the cheese bombs and the mac n cheese pizza—both were absolutely delicious. The cheese bombs were perfectly golden on the outside and filled with rich, gooey cheese inside—definitely a must-try appetizer. And the mac n cheese pizza? Super creative and packed with flavor. The crust had that signature buttery crispness that made every bite satisfying. Great service, too. I’ll definitely be coming back!
F
Felicia J
9 contributions
24/5/25
• DoorDash order
The wings were lukewarm and hard to chew. The pizza crust was tough. Waste of $50.Twice-Baked WingsBuild Your Own Square
D
Danielle R
1 contributions
26/6/24
• DoorDash order
First time trying this place. We got a half pepperoni and half cheese Build Your Own 16" pizza and the Parmesan Butter Bites. They both were amazing. Best pizza we have tried in a while. Definitely ordering from here again.
A
Allison N
1 contributions
13/12/24
• DoorDash order
It was good - probably would have been better right out of the oven/if we lived a bit closer but we liked it. The salad was fresh and not wilted, and the pizza was good.
