We order from here often. The bread on the Milano was stale and literally killed the roof of my mouth so 1/4 was eaten. The cheesesteak was half the size as normal. Utterly disappointing all around. Food is all around inconsistent and should be similar no matter who makes it. Standards are important.
K
Keziah D
1 contributions
18/1/25
• DoorDash order
Had The Real Cheesesteak for the first time today and it was a 10/10! I definitely recommend it. I will be getting this time and time again. Fresh ingredients, soft bread and the sub was very meaty and full ! I loved it
H
Heather S
Local Expert • 36 contributions
23/3/25
• DoorDash order
The Real Cheesesteak was really good. Lot of reviewers compared to Philadelphia cheesesteak & ive never had one while in phili, but wow this was a tasty sub. Zero percent greasy. So delicious. As good as best cheesesteak any of us have ever eaten in Baltimore city or NewYork. We ordered it as suggested on menu- on a baguette with cheddar & cherry peppers - peppers were cooked into meat & cheese was melted all though - had little kick but not too spicy for the old folks to eat. Was perfect. We will be ordering again. So good. The French Fries were meh & the Baked Ziti was way too dry & way too salty - too much grated parm, no one ate either of these. but no one cared cuz The Real Cheesesteak were so good we all just shared those & tossed the other food.
S
Stephanie P
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
2/9/23
• DoorDash order
Eataliano is my new favorite! The Real Philly Cheesesteak is unbelievably good, exactly what you'd expect in a Philly. The Super Meatball Parmigiana was also incredible, with plenty of cheese and tomato goodness. The Tiramisu is the best I've had in a long time, including from fancy Italian restaurants. You can't go wrong ordering from Eataliano!
M
Melissa G
3 contributions
27/9/22
• DoorDash order
So, so EXCELLENT. I was very impressed with the quality of everything we ordered, it kinda blew me away! The Eggplant Parmigiana was wonderful and comforting AND came with cheesy garlic bread(!), the pasta Greek Pasta Salad was tangy and delicious, and OMG the Cerignola Green Olives were perfect. The Creme Brulée & Berries was gorgeous- truly a work of art!
