This was my first time ever ordering from here! I was extremely impressed! The flavor was amazing. It was cooked just right, and I loved the texture of the crust. I will definitely be ordering again! I would definitely say order a pizza for each person if you're pretty hungry. if I would have had a guest over, one pizza would not have been enough.
N
Nina P
Local Expert • 33 contributions
21/9/24
• DoorDash order
PSA: these are 10", 6 slice pizzas with a side of spicy ranch for dipping.....
I ordered 2 1. Classic Cheese and Sauce pizzas, and as you can see in the pics, they look vastly different - as if there's no standard when making them.
After reading the reviews, I was hoping to be wowed, and decided to spend the money ($29 + tip) to try it out...unfortunately, it did absolutely nothing for me. One of the pizzas was visibly burnt & I learned the hard way that the burnt taste permeates the entire slice. There's no way getting around that taste.
I didn't care for the side of spicy ranch - a side of spicy marinara would have been perfection, and may have helped mask the burnt crust taste.
Overall 5/10. I would never waste my money on this ever again. In fact, I prefer Andreas Pizza - even Little Caesars or Pizza Hut - over this.
A
Areli S
2 contributions
21/7/25
• DoorDash review
chorizo pizza w/steak was solid
pepperoni with Canadian bacon & Italian sausage 🤌good af .The cheese sticks are good as well, the marinara sauce i loved. This place just uses over all great ingredients, they are small pies tho definitely order 2 or more
R
Rae H
Emerging Expert • 41 contributions
18/5/25
• DoorDash order
Be aware that the pizza size is small. I don't have a ruler handy, but I'm guessing about 10". $16 for a one item 10" is not what I would call a good price. The crust is thin, which would be fine if it were not also soggy. The sauce had no flavor, and unlike what it appears to be in the photo, the pepperoni slices are really large which makes it harder to get that nice, crisp edge on it. This was my first order from El Hornito and it was disappointing. I won't be going back.
S
Steven S
Emerging Expert • 9 contributions
8/9/24
• DoorDash review
This is THE BEST pizza I've ever had in Woodbury. Everything was fresh, flavorful, with the perfect amount of cheese on an airy crust. Also their marina and ranch sauces are TOP TIER. Totally worth the money considering the quality of these pizzas.
