Decent pizza. Tasty sauce and the roasted onions are great. Its so big that the dough doesn't get cooked all the way in some spots. The house salad was the star for me.
C
Cara D
1 contributions
6/3/25
• DoorDash order
This spot is amazing! For the price and quality it's un matched. The Garlic Knots reign supreme as well as te pizza.
K
Kayla W
1 contributions
10/6/22
• DoorDash order
Visiting from Missouri and wanted pizza that wasn't the standard delivery. Fat Sully's did not disappoint! Huge pizza with plenty of left overs. I highly recommend the white pizza with spinach and artichokes! It tastes just like spinach and artichoke dip! Definitely wish this place was closer to home!
J
Joey P
4 contributions
1/1/25
• DoorDash order
Perhaps it was Doordash's fault because they pay their drivers like garbage and couldnt find a driver, so we waited over an hour after the order was confirmed. But it was incredibly cold, the crust was stale, the anchovies had the consistency of gummy worms, the wings were difficult to peel the meat from the bone. Overall incredibly disappointing from a place that usually is a place I brag about.
M
Matthew C
3 contributions
17/1/25
• DoorDash order
The pizza is always great but they take too long to make it, the doordash driver had to wait 15 plus minutes at the the store and messaged me they weren't even that busy so not sure what the problem is but they need to be faster
