Since 2009, Gencarelli's has provided the greatest authentic Italian cuisine to the Lyndhurst neighborhood. Robert and Carmelo, the owners/cousins, offer a pleasant dining experience.
Chef Robert Ust…
Seafood marechiara was huge as well as the chicken piccata and pene vodka which we added chicken to. I would definitely recommend ordering one meal for two. Overall the meals were good & tasty .I just feel like the seasoning wasn't there maybe some more garlic in the sauce?
C
Caitlin L
2 contributions
24/1/25
• DoorDash order
Veal Parmigiana huge sub. Freshly cooked and great flavor.
Rice Ball comes as 2 pieces
J
Janet F
4 contributions
17/8/23
• DoorDash review
Consistently good, great customer service and large portions so I can have lunches this week. Highly recommend
K
Kan H
4 contributions
17/8/24
• DoorDash order
Overpriced for the special pizza. Smaller size and not as tasty as other place
K
Kelvin W
3 contributions
9/5/25
• DoorDash order
The cauliflower pizza is great! I added grilled shrimp and it was wonderful!
