Gerald DeGidio and his family opened the Italian Pie Shoppe in Eagan in 1976. At the time, the restaurant was located in what is today known as the smoking room or first dining room.
The restaurant w…
I always get the special 6 combo. Because it's the best deal and it is also the best pizza that they have (in my opinion). I choose green olives. My best friend chooses black olives and my husband loves the deep dish, meat lovers, personal pizza. We have found this to be one of our favorite family dinners at least once a month if not more. If you are looking for a good deep dish pizza, or if you like that cracker thin crust, this is the place for you.
R
Roger S
Emerging Expert • 18 contributions
10/10/23
• DoorDash order
Italian Pie Shoppe's deep dish is consistently outstanding. Super crisp shell (no mouthfuls of mushy doughy crust here) with very tomato forward sauce and lotsof yummy toppings. The composition and cook on this one was absolute perfection.
M
Maddie D
4 contributions
25/3/25
• DoorDash order
The "Garlic Bread" is not at all what is pictured and is actually 4 pieces of toast. Not much flavor except bread and oil. The Meat Lover Combo was poorly constructed so all the meat falls off when you pick it up. The crust has a good texture but has no flavor.
R
Roger S
Emerging Expert • 18 contributions
6/2/23
• DoorDash order
Bellisima y deliziosa! My first time here and it won’t be my last!!! It’s a deep dish BUT the crust is like a bowl made of thin, crispy crust. Not the thick, mushy dough of other ‘pan’ pizzas. Sooooo good.
Sauce is perfectly tangy, lots of delicious toppings and it was perfectly cooked.
If you haven’t tried this place, you should. Even if (especially if) you’ve tried pan pizza other places and didn’t like it.
D
Daniella V
1 contributions
3/12/23
• DoorDash order
Growing up in Chicago I feel I am a bit more harsh on pizza reviews since I grew up with some amazing pizza. With that being said we think this place is one of the best in town. From the pizza to the service we have always had a great experience.
