Josie’s Pizza Hilltop History
Placid Catalfina immigrated to the US on December 22, 1920 from Sicily, Italy at the young age of 13 years, along with his family. He sailed into New York Harbor on the…
one of the best homemade pizza shops. doughs mixed fresh in shop. the pepperoni is old world pep. the fried mushrooms are to die for.
S
Sarah S
Emerging Expert • 15 contributions
20/4/25
• DoorDash order
New to the area, definitely consider myself a "pizza connoisseur", and this place did NOT disappoint! Great tavern style "Ohio" pizza, gooey cheese, sauce had good salt and acidty, and OW pep was loaded up! Had enough moisture that I'm sure the leftovers will be perfect in the oven or air fryer!
Will def return!
J
Joe B
Emerging Expert • 78 contributions
5/3/25
• DoorDash order
Crispy Pepperoni (Pep Only)Stromboli SubOnion RingsGarden Salad (Large) all awesome as usual!
J
Joe B
Emerging Expert • 78 contributions
1/3/25
• DoorDash order
Shrimp DinnerChicken Nuggets (8)Onion Rings all amazing!