Great sauce and pepperoni I really like the amount of cheese and the little crunchy edges
M
Moriah H
2 contributions
13/12/24
• DoorDash order
The pizza is NOTHING like the pictures. While the flavor was good, the crust was paper thin (we are good with New York style, don't get me wrong), the crust was soggy and the meat was lacking. The mozzarella was the furthest from fresh as were any of the other ingredients. 1 hour of wait time, $40 for 2 pizzas and the bowling alley makes it better than this.
T
Taylor T
1 contributions
8/3/25
• DoorDash order
I'm no fan of leaving bad reviews. the pizza was tiny. the Pepperoni Pizza tasted fine. But for the price and the serving size, I hate to say it, but the insanity is real here. Straight from NY is just as good, but you actually get a pizza. I'm not trying to be that guy. but I don't get it. The pepp was good. The regular cheese pizza is not for the kiddos. The taste is way too ripe. Maybe I just dont know good pizza.
C
Chris H
1 contributions
3/4/25
• DoorDash order
Door dash told me my Pepperoni Pizza was ready for pickup. So I drove down after waiting 20 minand they were not busy at all and the guys working said " oh yeah I'll get right on that" so I waited another 7 min or so for them to cook a paper thin Pepperoni Pizza I'm not exaggerating. if they doubled the dough and charged say $20 bucks I'd say it's worth it, but until then I wouldn't recommend it, or go back. The flavor was good. I was just still hungry
J
James C
3 contributions
12/7/24
• DoorDash order
Let's make it clear: it's really, really good pizza. Tastes great. No complaints there. But Salem has a a decent number of options if you're looking for really good pizza, and when it comes to the cost-to-portion ratio, it can't compete. I'm glad I ordered when there was a deal going on. I imagine the cost is more reasonable if you're walking in and ordering at the restaurant itself but I probably won't be ordering again on DoorDash. Overall, it's (again) great food and I'd love to see them succeed as a business but I can't justify the cost when you can get larger pizzas with more customization options from other pizza spots that are just as good.
