The Reuben is Outstanding with its taste and Flavor. Money well spent. Now let me talk about this Spud. These are the biggest potatoes that I have seen. There is so much there that I had to take a break of 30 minutes before eating the Reuben. You will not go hungry If you eat a meal like this. Money well spent. As of right now I cannot move. Please try McAlister's Deli.
M
Michael H
Local Expert • 18 contributions
15/11/24
• DoorDash order
My second order from McAlister's and just as good as the first. Got the buy 2, half Memphian & half Max Spud. Sandwich is very flavorful, the bread was a little rough but not enough to distract from the taste. The spud was nice & hot, a little skimpy on the toppings compared to the first one I ordered. Still had great flavor & was large enough to be a whole spud from other restaurants so I was happy.
Will order from them again, they have a nice variety of food. Kind of the same things as any other sandwich place but I've really liked what I've had so far.
M
Michael H
Local Expert • 18 contributions
26/6/25
• DoorDash order
My second order from McAllisters & it was excellent! Got the Choose 2 & wanted to keep it simple. Ham & Cheese melt & half a Max Spud. The sandwich was just perfect, nice soft bread & the classic ham/cheese brought back a lot of childhood memories. The Spud was the best I had in a long time. Everything melted together in a tasty blend. It didn't even need salt & pepper like I always use. I haven't eaten this much in one sitting in quite some time but I wolfed this down! Thoroughly enjoyed it & will definitely order from them again.
R
RICHARD H
Local Expert • 913 contributions
14/12/23
• DoorDash order
Worst Potato that I have had in a long time. A really small container of butter, no salt & pepper. No Sour cream, no fork or spoon. Potato was warm not hot. Had a small amount of Bacon. Grilled ham and cheese was not even warm. The Ice Tea was warm with no ice.
L
Lindsay D
8 contributions
24/8/24
• DoorDash order
McAlister's has gotten sloppy. My sandwich had mangled bread and the neatis all on one piece. The nacho chips were all crushed. Gallon of tea was missing altogether. Last time we ordered missing items as well. They used to be so good. Now consistently sub par.
