McAlister's is a great deli to visit in Tallahassee. Their meats are high quality and properly cut, the bread is toasted well, and their sides are delicious. They are a little expensive compared to other sandwich shops but well worth it.
A
Anne F
Emerging Expert • 86 contributions
17/10/23
• DoorDash order
Make the best BLT and avocado sandwich in this town. And somehow they manage to make it in such a way that all the ingredients stay nicely enclosed in the bread which makes it much more enjoyable to eat without things falling out all over the place.
B
Beverly G
Emerging Expert • 28 contributions
16/10/24
• DoorDash order
The BLT had one piece ofbacon and tomato It wa all lettuce and avos on soggy bread.I ordered no avocado and thats all I got in every bite. The grilled cheese was hard as a rock. I was very disappointed in what I received.
A
Arctavia D
1 contributions
1/4/25
• DoorDash review
I'm so disappointed in this restaurant. I ordered kids Auntie Anne's pretzel dog, 2 macadamia nut cookies, and a large sweet tea. The pretzel dogs were burnt and cold. I didn't get any cookies, and the tea tasted watered down. I feel as though I was robbed of food and money.
B
Barry W
1 contributions
18/9/24
• DoorDash review
Not the best experience, but the taste was decent. Went to pick it up and was missing soup. They verified it was missing and had it out quickly. I ordered a half salad and half ultimate nachos. The picture shows it wasn't that. It didn't even qualify as their normal nachos! I expected better out of this normally consistent location.
