Located in the heart of downtown Potsdam, McDuff’s Pub is your go-to spot for delicious pub fare, ice-cold drinks, and a lively atmosphere. From our famous wings to handcrafted burgers and fresh local…
The food was good! THE SIGNATURE was tasty, I asked for medium and it was more on the medium rare side but still good. Ordered extra marinara with my appetizer and didnt recieve it. Overall just minor things and would order again.
D
Dillon M
4 contributions
4/5/25
• DoorDash review
I placed an order when what I wanted was originally out of stock elsewhere, so I thought I'd order wings from here and dessert. The Bone-in Medium buffalo were fine -not the best but not the worst I've had. The problem I had lays with the other 2 items I ordered.
The extra crispy, extra buttery Garlic Parmesan boneless wings tasted like buttered toast. Not terrible if you wanted buttered toast, not good if you wanted chicken wings. Not good to order extra sauce extra crispy and get little to no sauce and texture like a moist crouton. Not wet, just...moist.
Then the Lava Cake. I was surprised it came with ice cream (plus) and disappointed it didn't have a lava center, was dry, and dense (negative). The flavor was good for a brownie! Definitely not worth 17$ though. It definitely gave a "Baked then frozen then baked again to reheat" texture.
I don't know if it was an off night for them but it wasn't the most delicious thing we had.
PS
I didn't get my blue cheese.
F
Francesca B
1 contributions
8/3/25
• DoorDash order
MyTRADITIONAL POUTINE had NO gravy and almost no cheese. I went to check in case I was supposed to ADD the gravy, and it only had an option for extra. So there WAS supposed to be gravy. Like poutine is supposed to have. I meant to order the vegetarian wings and accidentally ordered the BONELESS WINGS - 6. I sucked it up and ate them anyway, but there were definitely bones in the wings. NOT satisfied 🙄
L
L K
1 contributions
9/5/25
• DoorDash review
Requested a medium well burger. As you can see, it's very well done including burnt top and bottom buns.
K
kait k
Emerging Expert • 14 contributions
1/3/25
• DoorDash order
THE BIG SMASH tasted good but the bottom bun and fries were pretty soggy unfortunately. Fries were under cooked and not as good as ive had before. MOZZERELLA TRIANGLES were pretty good.
