The pizza was smaller than I expected but it was really good. I didn't expect it to look like the picture on the app but it did, there was the perfect amount of pepperoni. To whomever made my tiny pizza you need a raise. Because you are doing the most to make sure the pizza was the best even though I ordered so late. Thank you!
R
Ryan C
Emerging Expert • 13 contributions
8/7/24
• DoorDash order
Paid $33 for a large Pepperoni, the size of this pizza would easily be a medium anywhere else. I haven't had Mountain Mike's in years because of the price vs quality, but again I am reassured that the price does not justify what is received. There are other pizza joints that are better than this.
J
Juan F
1 contributions
14/6/25
• DoorDash order
Not What I Expected
I recently ordered a pizza and unfortunately, my experience was less than satisfactory. Upon opening the box, I was immediately struck by the lack of freshness in the pizza. The crust looked a bit stale and had an unappealing, limp texture instead of the desired crispness.
As I took my first bite, the disappointment continued. The toppings tasted lacking in flavor, and the cheese had a rubbery consistency that hinted it had been sitting out for too long. The overall taste was reminiscent of an old pizza that had lost its appeal, not the vibrant, fresh flavors I was hoping for.
The sauce, which should have added some zest, was bland and didn't complement the pizza at all. It felt like a missed opportunity, as a good sauce can really elevate a pizza.
I expected a delicious, satisfying meal, but instead, I felt let down by the overall freshness and quality. Unfortunately, this experience did not leave me wanting to return for more. I hope their quality improves, as there’s nothing better than a fresh, hot slice of pizza. Overall, I hope it's not like this next time.
B
Bob K
Local Expert • 254 contributions
14/4/24
• DoorDash order
Pepperoni Pizza was freshly prepared, hot, not soggy but not too crispy , lots of delicious cheese and delicious iconic cupped Pepperoni very delicious and the " small" option of pizza size was a perfect lunch .
B
Bob K
Local Expert • 254 contributions
16/5/24
• DoorDash order
mini Pepperoni pizza had crispy but not dried out delicious crust; lots of Pepperoni
; New! Jalapeño Not-Knots™ were perfect amount of spicyness, garlic and cheesy very delicious - both freshly baked.
