**Review of Mr. Pickles Sandwich Shop**
I recently had the pleasure of trying out Mr. Pickles Sandwich Shop, and I must say, it was an absolute delight. The ambiance was cozy and inviting, and the staff were friendly and attentive.
Now, let's talk about the food. I ordered the Kickin Chicken sandwich, and it was a flavor explosion! The chicken was perfectly seasoned and had just the right amount of kick to it. The fresh veggies and sauce complemented it perfectly, making each bite a delicious experience.
To accompany my sandwich, I opted for a large fountain drink and chips. The drink selection was impressive, and my soda was perfectly chilled. As for the chips, they were crispy and addictive, providing the ideal crunch alongside my sandwich.
Overall, my experience at Mr. Pickles Sandwich Shop was top-notch. From the mouthwatering Kickin Chicken sandwich to the refreshing fountain drink and crispy chips, everything exceeded my expectations. I'll definitely be returning for more of their tasty offerings.
T
Ted J
5 contributions
9/3/25
• DoorDash order
My wife and Ihave tried other sandwich shops here in Tracy and, to us, without question, Mr. Pickle's is THE BEST sandwich shop in town. The meats, bread and vegetables are always fresh. We've been patronizing Mr. Pickle's for a number of years and have never been disappointed.
L
Leah M
Local Expert • 36 contributions
7/9/22
• DoorDash order
I love Mr. Pickles where I'm from but Tracy location is so sub par that a pre packaged deli sandwich from the grocery store would be far superior. I had 1 good order a couple years ago but subsequent orders were so terrible I've given up on them. On a previous order we received 2 sandwiches and both were missing many requested ingredients and included ingredients that I requested be kept off. The avocado they put on both sandwiches was so brown that neither of us would eat ours...they looked like 2 day old leftovers. They did remember to put on the cranberry sauce last time but I had to deconstruct the sandwich to find it and when i did, it looked more like they just wiped a knife off on the bread that had cranberry residue on it...a barely perceptible pink wash skipped over just the center of the bread. This would be disappointing even if it were an included condiment but I paid a significant amount extra. There was roughly the same amount of mustard and mayo so saying it was dry is an understatement. After a long time I decided to give them another shot when we wanted a cold fresh dinner on a very hot day hoping it was a "once off" bad experience last time, but it was an equal disappointment. The Dutch Crunch roll was stale and flat (it tasted and looked like bread that hadn't risen) and the corner of my husbands sandwich roll was so hard it couldn't be bitten through. The turkey on my Big Jake was breaking down (what!!) and had the look and texture of shredded tuna. I took some turkey out of my sandwich to inspect it after feeling the mushy texture in my mouth and it easily fell apart between my fingers... so after eating less than 1/4 of it I couldn't eat anymore after seeing the meat. Both bad experiences were within 45 minutes of closing so maybe they don't bother to restock the counter with fresh ingredients and instead try to sell off the remaining ingredients toward the end of the night. However, I'm not going to waste $14 a sandwich to try again. I should be able to order a fresh sandwich regardless of closing time anyway. I'm so disappointed that my favorite sandwich chain is so terrible where I live. I gave 2 stars because I had 1 good sandwich from here before and they didn't forget any ingredients this last time, but after throwing away 3 out of 4 sandwiches from 2 orders I think 2 stars is more than generous.
T
Tatiana V
25 contributions
6/2/25
• DoorDash order
Best Cali Tuna out are always fresh & packed with good stuff! Worth it every time there! All sammiches are super
T
Tatiana V
25 contributions
24/12/23
• DoorDash order
Listen Listen Linda is my go to & always on point especially if you're super hungry!
The cookie with your order is a particularly nice touch🥰🍪
