AMAZING!!! 5 STARS! Deliciously sweet, ooey gooey & warm! My buddy and I are cookie connoisseurs and these are our new favs - Brookie, Oreo Brownie Cheesecake, Chocolate S'mores, Chocolate Chip, Red Velvet, and Cookies & Cream
P
Presley D
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
21/4/25
• DoorDash order
First time trying this place. Red Velvet cookies were my favorite! Delicious! Not sure if mine was just a not so good batch but honestly the store bought Nestle chocolate chip cookies are better. And the Oreo Brownie Cheesecake was bland, tasted like nothing. But the cookies are huge lol. Red Velvet was super tasty.
M
Marisa F
Local Expert • 27 contributions
26/6/24
• DoorDash order
I absolutely adore Night Owl Cookies! My favorite is the Oreo Brownie Cheesecake. I also love the Dirty Diana , Red Velvet , and the Chocolate Chip with cream cheese frosting added. The Birthday Cake cookie is also great. They always arrive so perfectly made. when I open the box, it is hard to start eating right away because of how beautiful they look! I have yet to be disappointed.
I will say that the Pride cookie threw me off a bit. I am not crazy about fruity cereal on cookies, or sour/fruity candy. It was pretty, though, and after taking the candy and cereal off, it tasted like a great sugar cookie.
No matter what, you HAVE to try Night Owl Cookies if you haven't already!
L
Latise C
3 contributions
20/12/24
• DoorDash order
These cookies are awful I shouldve got crumbl instead. They taste box made and the frosting was disgusting as well. Way too sweet. Not worth the price. Gret portion size but I would not order here again.
R
rae g
13 contributions
today
• DoorDash order
Ave Maria are amazing. Great summer flavor when you arent craving chocolate. Its a big cookie but not weighed down heavy with flavor. From the first bite I lnew this was gonna bea favorite. Its definitely one I could mindlessly pick up while say reading etc. I love the white chocolateDELISH
Dirty Diana is a THIIIIICK girl fr fr. Full flavor. No denying if there is Nutella. Its like a brownie seriously. This is a must if you are on some sad girl ish Esp that tome ofbthe month
Chocolate Chip its a massive classic. Its important to me that a chocolate chip cookie has a fanat cookie dough flavor. So that the chips dont over power & steal the show. Even with how covered these are with chips that cookie is just fantastic. So fresh so gooey
Night owl is truly the best. The winter park location is THE BEST
Like i have gotten dubia cookies every week.....
