all my preferences were met, and the pizza was still hot out the oven when it arrived. I really enjoyed the New York style crust, perfect crisp on the edges, and the sauce is the best out of the pizza chains, perfect level acidity without the extra amsweetness.
Z
Zachary L
Emerging Expert • 6 contributions
9/9/23
• DoorDash order
perfect size pizza for 1, love the Spicy Garlic Sauce, and the extra Banana Peppers is a must. the pizza crisps up really nice at this size, and my pizza has always arrived pretty hot. As far as big pizza chains go, I think Papa johns wins in the pizza sauce game.
J
Jennifer L
1 contributions
11/5/25
• DoorDash order
I paid $1.50 to add beef and literally only had two pieces of beef on the whole pizza. The pizza was made sloppy.
B
Braxton B
2 contributions
10/6/25
• DoorDash order
Didn't include forkfor pasta. The pizza Chicken Alfredo Papa Bowl is delicious andI'd definitely order it again. The portion is huge andit was very fresh.
C
Christy J
Emerging Expert • 15 contributions
29/9/21
• DoorDash order
Ordered the Shaq-a-roni - this was the second time- this particular papa johns seems to do it a different way than the rest of them, maybe they're trying to save money, I don't know, but they skimped on the pepperoni & cheese- it's supposed to be double the ingredients, but this particular store doesn't put double on, it's the normal amount at best. I've had others, and they were delicious- this one was "meh", nothing special and I doubt I would order it again.
