First time ordering from Rahway Bagels and the breakfast sandwiches were delicious. The homefries were ok but, the portion was big and could easily be split between two people. To-go packaging was really good too
S
Suzanne L
Local Expert • 42 contributions
17/6/25
• DoorDash order
as always, they deliver you the best.the bagel sandwich as always nice. eggs are perfect, and sausage was cooked. Good and hash brown were cooked perfectly. not soggy
N
Nick P
2 contributions
23/6/24
• DoorDash order
My Taylor Ham, Egg and Cheese was $8.55. Added Double Egg, Salt, Pepper and Ketchup. Got non of the extras and was presented with something that has the height of a kitchen sponge. The bagels I would fight my mother for and you can tell are made with passion. The sandwiches are down bad and highway robbery.
D
Dan B
1 contributions
28/12/24
• DoorDash order
Bagels are SO fresh, many times when I order the plastic bag the bagels come in is literally steamed up because the bagels are so fresh and hot. Pork roll egg and pepper jack cheese is also delicious. Love the everything bagels heard the cheddar is good too.
V
Vinny S
23 contributions
1/2/25
• DoorDash order
Bagels are delicious, but not enough cream cheese. *Bagels with butter- please wrap in foil, the butter melts all over the other items and bag.
