After having pizza from nearly every place in the Hilliard area we decided to try sextons. This was the best pizza we've ever had, anywhere, ever. It has the right mix of ingredients, was perfectly tasty, cooked to perfection, and delivered quickly. Keep up the good work!
D
David S
1 contributions
24/4/25
• DoorDash order
The Jar of Sexton's Ranch, the Birthday Cake, and the Red Velvet cupcakes were insanely good. Good enough for me to order another two cupcakes for the late night snack. The Jar of Sexton's Ranch was awesome. The pizza was really good, even my child who hates East Village Pepperoni ate it. But the highlight was definitely the cupcakes and ranch.
D
Debbie C
Emerging Expert • 14 contributions
20/3/25
• DoorDash order
Second time orderng , and this transplanted New Yorker stll thinks this is the best pizza in Ohio. I'm looking forward to eating my way through the menu! Delicious!
D
Debbie C
Emerging Expert • 14 contributions
7/3/25
• DoorDash order
If I could leave 10 stars, I would.
I lived in NYC my wh life -- a place where phe pizza is everywhere. Columbus-area pizza ne measured up, and I've been visiting since my daughter first got to OSU in 2012.
I moved here last year snd thought I'd never find puzza like "home" -- unt today!! Thank you for making me a little less homesick with a delicious pizza w perfect crust!!
D
Deb P
4 contributions
1/2/25
• DoorDash review
Best pizza in town, FOR SURE!!! It got here so quick & was hot & delicious!! Super impressed that the delivery didnt affect the quality of enjoyment at all!!! My new favorite place in around!! :)
