This site uses our own and third-party cookies and similar technologies to ensure our site and services function, personalize user experiences, analyze and improve website performance and content, and for advertising purposes. For more information please review our Cookie Policy. Click “Essential only” to reject non-essential cookies, or “Close” to continue without changing your preferences.
Yo Mamma, now that's a sandwich! Seriously, this gem of a sandwich place is in the league of Katz's Deli. I split the humungous whole chicken salad sandwich my wife and there was enough left over for supper. Mind you, we're old folks, and old farts don't have big appetites anymore. Still if was a strapping young lad in my 20's, I doubt I would have walked away feeling hungry. And the knish was a genuine GABILA'S KNISH (I can tell because I was born and raised in NYC).
J
J S
Local Expert • 37 contributions
24-06-28
• DoorDash review
They have the best sandwiches in the Syracuse area, and I have never gone hungry. The Brookyln Pickle Special Sandwich is my go too
R
Rhonda W
1 contributions
2 days ago
• DoorDash order
This is not the usual Brooklyn Pickle Chicken Salad sandwiches.The chicken salad is normally falling out of the sandwich. I had to move the lettuce around to find the chic salad. Also, side note, my special request was for garlic pickles on the sandwich. We got 2 slices of dill, not on sandwich. I mention because I called the manager about the sandwiches and said something about the pickles. All she said was sorry, next time you're in let us know and we'll throw in some extra pickles. I'd rather them throw in some chicken salad! How disappointing, never had this problem and we've ordered many sandwiches. I would have had them remade and sent out to customer.
C
Christi B
3 contributions
24-06-12
• DoorDash order
Phenomenal as always. Sandwich was huge and tasty/. Bread fresh.love the pickles. Great choices for cookies, brownies. One of my favorite paces. So glad I can now have it delivered
M
Maria C
1 contributions
25-06-19
• DoorDash order
Better off making your own sandwhich at home. They put two slices of salami on some bread and stacked the rest of the sandwich with handful of lettuce. You would've thought that I ordered a lettuce sandwich. The taste doesn't live up to its hype.