This site uses our own and third-party cookies and similar technologies to ensure our site and services function, personalize user experiences, analyze and improve website performance and content, and for advertising purposes. For more information please review our Cookie Policy. Click “Essential only” to reject non-essential cookies, or “Close” to continue without changing your preferences.
Checking if the site connection is secured...
4.5(5k+ ratings)•
DashPass•
Italian
•
Store Info
DashPass
4.5(5k+ ratings)•
$$•Italian
Being in Orlando doesn't mean you can't eat like you are in the Big Apple. If you're craving a slice of that heavenly NYC pie, look no further than NYPD Pizza.
NYPD Pizza is determined to make a real …
Let’s get to the food—because WOW. We decided to try a little bit of everything, and we were blown away by how delicious it all was. First up, the pizza: it was hands down the best pizza I’ve ever had in Florida! The crust was the perfect balance of crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. You can tell they put a lot of care into their dough. The sauce was rich, slightly tangy, and had just the right amount of seasoning. And the toppings? Fresh, flavorful, and generously portioned. We ordered a classic pepperoni and a veggie pizza, and both were absolute perfection.
Next, the Italian subs. These were a game-changer! The bread was soft but sturdy enough to hold all the delicious fillings. The meats were high-quality and packed with flavor, and the toppings (lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and their house dressing) were so fresh they felt like they’d just been picked. It’s not easy to find an Italian sub done right, but this one hit every mark and then some.
And then there are the garlic knots. Oh. My. Goodness. These were some of the best garlic knots I’ve ever tasted! They were soft and pillowy on the inside with a beautiful golden crust on the outside. The buttery garlic coating was absolutely addictive, and the sprinkle of herbs took them to the next level. We couldn’t stop eating them, and honestly, I wish we had ordered more!
What really stood out to me was the consistency. Every single item we tried was cooked perfectly and tasted like it was made with love and care. It’s rare to find a place that excels at so many different menu items, but NYPD Pizza absolutely nailed it.
A
Amanda P
Local Expert • 21 contributions
25-05-16
• DoorDash order
Everything was pretty decent although it had to travel a long time so some things were cold and the chicken wings were steamed and not crispy. Chicken on the margarita needed to be cut out smaller and everything lacked seasoning maybe this is traditional NY pizza. I'm not sure but I'm used to more seasoning. I like that you could fold it and the ranch was delicious. I would order here again although I would try something different. Portions were great also.
N
Natasha M
1 contributions
24-07-11
• DoorDash order
I'm unsure what happened bc usually the pizza is amazing but this time I couldn't taste the hot honey and it was just not made well, the mozzarella sticks were stale tasting and burnt out. the garlic were the only good thing we got and they weren't that great this time either. was disappointed and will debate ordering again
L
Lorena M
2 contributions
23-08-25
• DoorDash order
Decepcionada! La peor pizza que nos hemos comido, los ingredientes no eran frescos, especialmente la salchicha, la pizza congelada del supermercado sabe mejor. Los Garlic Knots 5 estrellas la pizza 0 estrellas
R
Rhonda G
3 contributions
21-12-10
• DoorDash order
The cheese pizza slice was petrified it was so old and dry, the pepperoni had 2 slices and was loaded with extra cheese, which I didn't order and the sausage was the wrong sausage on the slice again smothered in extra cheese which I didn't order. I ended up throwing all 3 slices in the garbage.
