This site uses our own and third-party cookies and similar technologies to ensure our site and services function, personalize user experiences, analyze and improve website performance and content, and for advertising purposes. For more information please review our Cookie Policy. Click “Essential only” to reject non-essential cookies, or “Close” to continue without changing your preferences.
Blown away by how good our food was from Pickles NY Deli! We got the Brooklyn Reuben (half pastrami, half corned beef), patty melt, and matzo ball soup. The meat on the Reuben was incredible - lean, juicy, and flavorful without being too salty. Basically it made me quit doing traditional St. Patrick's day, I'll just be ordering from Pickles instead from here on out. My wife enjoyed her patty melt on fresh rye bread, and the onion rings were great too - breading was spot-on and the dipping sauce had the perfect amount of horseradish to add a good kick. Matzo ball soup was excellent as well, the lemon-infused chicken broth took the soup to the next level. To sum up, Pickles clearly cares about making their customers happy through great food - I am very impressed and look forward to trying the rest of their menu. Bonus points to the Dasher who got our food here fast and still piping hot!
R
Renae S
3 contributions
25-05-08
• DoorDash order
Brooklyn Reuben this was an excellent sandwich. There was a lot of meat on it. You definitely could tell the meat was cooked in house. My only complaint was there wasn't enough dressing as it had soaked into the bread. I also got the pasta salad which wasn't my favorite as it had too much vinegar.
When I got the sandwich it was a little soggy but I think it was because it was delivered instead of hot in the restaurant. It was so big I have lunch for tomorrow.
This place is definitely worth the visit, I just wouldn't have it delivered.
Go try it, you won't be disappointed!
B
Bella G
6 contributions
23-08-19
• DoorDash order
The New Yorker is INCREDIBLE. I ordered the lobster bisque as a side, and I do not have the words to describe how delicious it is! And it's a pretty large portion, too. There's definitely enough for two meals, but I'm still going to order again tomorrow.
Apparently the Meatball Parmesan Hoagie is really good, too, but my husband inhaled it before I could snag even a bite.
J
Jennifer S
2 contributions
25-03-27
• DoorDash order
Huge delicious sandwich! My husband asked where I bought it from and instantly looked it up and said when are we going AGAIN?! Classic ReubenPickle Barrel great selection and very savory!
S
Stephanie E
6 contributions
23-01-15
• DoorDash order
First time trying Pickles but after hearing so many people talk about it I decided to. Bronx Cheer sounded amazing to me because I hate sauerkraut but love Coleslaw and it didn't dissapoint. The Sandwich is absolutely ginormous for starters. I barely got through half of it. It's delicious. The Turkey Pesto Panini was also delicious with the au jus it comes with. I also tried the Fried Pickles and I have to say they are just average and for the $8.99 price tag I was expecting more (quantity wise and flavor wise). The sauce it comes with was better suited for the fries the sandwich came with then the Pickles. Overall I'm satisfied with my food and will definitely try something else again.
