Wow! The FILET MIGNON* was perfectly cooked. Juicy, flavorful, and buttery steak that just melts in your mouth. The loaded potatoes were amazing and Mac n cheese didnt miss. My man loved the TOM'S SOLE, perfectly cooked flakey fish with a delicious parmesan crust and sauce. I rarely review delivery food but 54th street did THAT GOOD!
F
Frank C
17 contributions
27/06/25
• DoorDash order
Best meal I've had in months. These 'CENTER CUT' BABY BACK RIBS are the most perfect ribs I've ever had. Got the loaded mash in hindsight wish I got a baked potato. Beans are perfect. Kid's KID FRIED SHRIMP with cocktail sauce was yum.
T
Taylor M
5 contributions
31/07/24
• DoorDash order
Food was delicious! I will only eat spear cut FRIED PICKLES from 54th St & no where else - always top tier. First time trying the CRAB CAKES & they did not disappoint. The Mac was daddying - Good Soup *slurps soup*
A
Adam H
1 contributions
17/05/23
• DoorDash order
Ordered when they opened. Fries are soggy and undercooked. Two cherry limeades cost $11.10 before tax is 80% ice. Gringo dip is watery and flavorless. Sad to see one of my favorite places go downhill
A
Amanda D
3 contributions
01/03/25
• DoorDash order
This cheesecake is LEGITIMATELY better than cheesecake factory. I always get and extra strawberry puree sauce,.. Easily the best cheesecake I've ever had!
