Bagel Fair
4.9(1k+ ratings)•
European•
Store Info
4.9(1k+ ratings)•
$•European
Bagel Fair Incorporated, established in 1975, is a 2nd generation family owned business located in Nora Plaza Shopping Center (across from Target). Bagels are made fresh daily, from a family recipe ov…
Full Menu
7:00 am - 1:45 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Reviews1k+ ratings • 20+ public reviews
4.9
of 5 stars
M
Madison C
3 contributions19/06/24
• DoorDash orderI moved to indiana last year from the east coast and it has taken me almost the whole year to find a half decent bagel. THIS PLACE IS AMAZING!!! Top notch, new york style bagels and bagel sandwiches. The Jalapeno Cheddar Cream Cheese and Everything Bagels are fantastic.
C
Cosmo B
4 contributions03/04/25
• DoorDash orderTruly a great meal!, minus the sheet rock they used to make the lonely Pumpernickel Bagel which wasnt even wrapped; just dropped in the bag. Not that it would matter; I bent a stainless steel knife trying to cut it. Depending on where you live it might even be considered a wéapon it's so hard haha.
The B.L.T. was superb, and more than enough bacon for even 2 or 3 more sandwiches haha.
The Jalapeño Cheddar Cream Cheese Spread was also a delight, the craftsmanship of it is phenomenal. It had plenty on it!
Yoo-Hoo was; as always; a staple of deliciousness.
T
Talli W
1 contributions15/06/25
• DoorDash orderBagel fair will always be my favorite! Bagels showed up warm and fresh!
C
Curtis G
4 contributions02/02/24
• DoorDash orderScallion Cream Cheese Spread generously spread on a Jalapeño Bagel
A
Abby S
6 contributions10/12/21
• DoorDash reviewas a lover of all things bagels I feel it gives me some validity of what constitutes as a GOOD bagel, and let me tell ya, these bagels are IT. When i saw they were added to doordash i audibly said to myself SHUT UP. This puts einsteins in the grave. 10/10
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Sandwiches
Just Bagels
Plain, sesame, poppy, everything, bialy, onion, garlic, salt, blueberry, cinnamon raisin, apple cinnamon cranberry, multi grain, pumpernickel or jalapeño cayenne.
Cream Cheese
8oz. Containers of cream cheese spread.
Bagels with Spread
A bagel with your choice of cream cheese or butter on it.