Borgata Pizza Cafe in Columbus, Ohio, is a top-rated Italian restaurant.
At Borgata, we're committed to offering only the freshest and best ingredients in our New York style pizza and handcrafted Ital…
I missed my NY pie when I moved back to Ohio. I had been looking for so long for a place that made a pie anywhere close to NY style. Borgata has one of the best NY style that I've found in Columbus!! I will definitely be ordering from here frequently!
M
Mostafa H
1 contributions
10/01/25
• DoorDash order
Pizza burnt again and the quantity of the Garlic w/Cheesec bread is way less than what you get when dine in.
H
Heather H
Local Expert • 329 contributions
18/02/24
• DoorDash order
The 12” Gluten Free Pizza has the best crust in the area. The sauce and seasoning was lack luster. I think they used vegan cheese instead of regular. Which was disappointing.
K
Katie S
3 contributions
18/05/23
• DoorDash review
As a first generation Sicilian American who spent nearly half of my childhood in NY, this is the by far the BEST pizza that Columbus has to offer. It's a couple extra bucks, but always so worth it
