We're two working-class guys who have spent our entire lives in this restaurant. We've worked in every aspect of the restaurant business, from dishwashing to executive management. We both had a dream …
One of the best local owned burger places on the Island! Kinda wish there was more cheese on the Cheese Fries, but I guess that could've made them soggy. My Cheeseburger was fantastic, 5 Piece Chicken Nuggets tasted real good & they were so crunchy! Milkshakes are on point too. I was going to take pics but I couldn't help myself, too busy digging in..
D
David J
Local Expert • 23 contributions
30/06/25
• DoorDash order
The Chipotle Black Bean Burger (Vegetarian) was incredibly flavorful. I didnt miss it being beef at all very satisfying.. The Onion Rings were extremely crunchy and delicious!! Boxcar Burgers have not ever let me down.. Incredibly flavorful food and out standing prices!!
K
Kevin L
2 contributions
06/09/24
• DoorDash order
Possibly one of the best Cheeseburgers I've had, like ever. Great taste, not messy, and not greasy like other burger places.
J
John D
Emerging Expert • 13 contributions
25/08/24
• DoorDash order
They make a darn good burger. Also The Third Rail sandwich is delicious with a great crunch. Their quality is always great and I have never had a bad experience here.
W
Whitney M
6 contributions
15/04/25
• DoorDash order
I always get exactly what I ordered. And you get a good amount of food for the price. The food always hits the spot whenever I just want classic American food.
