We love Indianapolis, and we had to bring a second location to the Broad Ripple Suburb. Located on Broad Ripple Avenue near the White River, Goodfellas Broad Ripple is an Indianapolis Staple.
this is the second time, out of the past 3 times, we have ordered where everything tastes like cleaner. Also, just very poorly put together. Cheese was basically only put on one side. On a positive note, the 20 oz bottle of coke was as expected.
Also, the Breadstick - D2D is just one long piece of rolled dough that is folded enough to fit in the box.
P
Pam M
Emerging Expert • 26 contributions
11/07/25
• DoorDash order
We do think their quality has gone downhill. Ordered a simple pep/mushroom pizza. The crust was awful. Flimsy and undercooked. And the sauce is sweet and underwhelming. The pizza as a whole was undercooked. Think we will take a break from Goodfellas. They really need to add an option or 2 for example...light sauce and well done.
T
Terra P
Emerging Expert • 9 contributions
19/05/25
• DoorDash order
Pizza was great but way over priced. 12" pizza delivered for $42.00?!? Used DoorDash since Good Fellows do not deliver. Way too expensive.
C
Chris W
10 contributions
04/01/25
• DoorDash order
$25+ for a 12" pizza is insane. Pizza was also not good, crust was amazing but eveything else was not worth the price. Will likely never order a full pizza from here again. Buying by the slice is much preferred.
T
Tessa R
6 contributions
20/01/25
• DoorDash order
So I think I paid an extra$1.5 or $2 for artichoke for 1/2 pizza and got ONE PIECE for tue whole half of pizza. Now i know better...prob won't order from here again...
Also the side of pasta salad wouldnt feed a kitten
