Everything was wrapped perfectly and so nothing got soiled on the way. The cheese curds were still melted and the sauce they have made it all come together beautifully. What a load of meat in these sandwiches!! These are not for the weak. It might make 3 meals for me but someone with a. Good appetite would be over the top happy.
T
Tristan C
2 contributions
03/03/24
• DoorDash order
got the garlic aioli cheesesteak, no extra add ons. opened the wrapper and first thing i see is meat piled sky high, falling out of the sandwich. if i had to rename this sandwich, it'd be Joy. this sandwich made me so happy to be alive. The old bay fries were perfectly crispy and the seasonings were delicious. 10/10 ordering again. best cheesesteaks in nyc.
A
Arlo P
9 contributions
14/12/24
• DoorDash order
Best Cheesesteak in Manhattan, hands down. Anytime I am in NYC, this is my go-to, consistently prepared perfectly with plenty of steak, nice balance of cheese and onions on a great roll. My man
A
Amanda G
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
25/06/25
• DoorDash order
Awesome cheese steaks. The bread is perfect and the portions are generous. 1 sando is 2 meals for me! Always comes super hot. Thanks Olde City!!
C
Christopher L
3 contributions
17/08/23
• DoorDash order
Best cheesesteak I have ever bought and portion is massive. Price is justified. I got the Garlic Aioli one. Ranch - Side was awesome too.
