Papa Johns Pizza (5339 Old Highway 5)
4.6(200+ ratings)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
DashPass
4.6(200+ ratings)•
$$•Pizzeria
Full Menu
10:00 am - 12:45 amFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
Featured Items
Reviews200+ ratings • 8 public reviews
4.6
of 5 stars
B
Barbara N
Local Expert • 77 contributions12/03/25
• DoorDash orderNew York Style Crust still very good after I got over the missing security seals
B
Barbara N
Local Expert • 77 contributions23/02/25
• DoorDash orderNew York Style Crust is excellent; I order often. Buffalo Wings were were very good too
B
Britney F
1 contributions20/02/23
• DoorDash orderPapa John's saved the day! I ordered twice and waited over three hours for Pizza Hut to deliver, but they never showed. Thank you, Papa John's and DoorDash!
S
SUSAN L
2 contributions21/11/24
• DoorDash orderEdges burned, crust was cold, dry & hard to tear apart & chew. Very sparse tomato sauce. Cheese was thick, burned in the center & overly cooked. Toppings appeared old, tasted flat with no flavor. Black olives were dry & tasteless. Pepperoni was either hiding or absent! Anchovies stiff & dry.
Maybe kept under heat light too long while waiting for driver? Couldn't chew or eat crust due to dryness/toughness. Even the pepper was shriveled, dry & the top edge & stem were brown & looked old.
Off night for Papa J. Usually decent but not tonight. 😥🍕
T
Tam W
1 contributions12/08/24
• DoorDash orderCheese sticks were over baked and dry. Maybe because they were about to close
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store