Our first time ordering but won't be our last. Food was fresh, hot and tasty! Meatball sub was perfect not to much sauce, jist right. Filet mignon salad was great, greens fresh and steak perfect temp. And if you like garlicky garlic bread you will love it from here!
K
Karlee F
Emerging Expert • 32 contributions
03/02/25
• DoorDash order
Fried Zucchini was amazing! Everything was hot and fresh. I wish Pizza 54 would include important descriptions for items like the buffalo cauliflower, adding that the cauliflower is deep fried. The kids pizza is a very generous size and nothing was left off my group's order.
J
Jessica I
6 contributions
30/10/24
• DoorDash order
I will start with the positive, lemon pepper wings rival our local fav. My son likes his plain and loved his also. That's why there are 3stars.
This was our first time trying Pizza 54, and did so because of the BOGO special on DD (which we used for the wings). I could not justify two pizzas so opted to split our BYO 12" Pizza in half. Pepperoni half, sausage and mushroom half. What we got was 2/3 pepperoni, 1/3 cheese, 1/3 sausage and mushroom (see pic), and not to mention the slices being completely off. Taste was okay, but again, I only had a few bites of a very small portion of small slices.
M
Mandy G
3 contributions
24/09/23
• DoorDash order
I've only tried this place once and I didnt get pizza. I'll go for the pizza next time. I got a Meatball Parm sandwich and to be honest, it was just ok. The meatballs didn't have much flavor, so a little disappointing. My side was the side salad. It looked great upon opening the box, but the greens didn't appear or taste very fresh. And I got six wings. I requested lemon pepper, all flats. I ended up getting all drums and half were lemon pepper and half were regular Buffalo. Overall this meal was a miss for me. It also seemed like my dasher was waiting for a while. I'm giving 2 stars for it being well packaged and I received a promotional discount off my total, so at least I didnt pay full price.
J
Justice L
1 contributions
26/03/24
• DoorDash review
Phenomenally delicious!!!! The #8 Meatball pizza and the lemon pepper wings were hot, fresh and most of all flavorful.
