"From 1848 to the present, families in northern New Jersey have enjoyed fresh dairy products from what became known as Applegate Farm. A 15-minute west of New York City to visit Applegate Farm. Go bac…
So natural and deliciously creamy! I have never had a sugar free ice cream as amazing as the cherry vanilla at Applegate. It is by far my favorite flavor and the family box makes it convenient for everyone to share their favorite treat!
M
Melitza M
Local Expert • 30 contributions
9/05/25
• DoorDash order
The Milk Shake flavor was strange. I selected cookies and cream and vanilla peanut butter but all i taste is straight up peanutbutter. Im guessing you selet 2 options and they choose for you? i thought they would've been mixed but i guess not? For the Hand Packed Ice Cream i had selected vanilla and strawberry and i thought it would have been half strawberry half vanilla but nope just vanilla. Please change the way you order, it is not correct and very misleading. very expensive too for the portions, better off ordering carvel. save ur money!
M
Meaghan M
2 contributions
4/07/22
• DoorDash order
I got 2 medium cups and they were filled to right below the top of the cup. Usually the icecream is filled to the top of the lid. It felt like the amount of ice-cream given was a small size cup. it was ~$18 dollars so thats why I am a little bothered
M
Mirna A
6 contributions
10/12/21
• DoorDash order
they could have actually added caramel and snickers since they charged for it...i mean i got one little piece of snicker and a dash of caramel...they have never skimped like that b4...the butterpecan wasn't even a scoop...the pistacchio was the only thing that was right...maybe i should stick to ice cream in the summer...
J
Jackie D
Local Expert • 60 contributions
16/07/23
• DoorDash order
Family Sundae Box worth it for the price !! Unbelievable amount of toppings also.
