Best "thin crust" Brooklyn New York Style X-Large 18'' Cheese Pizza - X-Large 18'' and I mean unequivocally the absolute best in Buffalo! The pizza is amazing! The Caesar Salad - Small is a nice fresh touch of green. We often order calamari also. Should not be missed. Definitely the best calamari in the area!
J
Jim C
3 contributions
19/09/24
• DoorDash order
The best New York Style X-Large 18'' Cheese Pizza - X-Large 18'' in all of Western NY! I am a pizza snob of the high order. Raised on NYC , NJ pizza and Jersey Shore boardwalk pies. This is on par, often better than that. If you like Buffalo style pizza it's only because you have not tried Brooklyn's Finest yet.
F
Frank D
Emerging Expert • 4 contributions
14/08/24
• DoorDash order
Ordered the New York Style Medium 14'' Cheese Pizza - Medium 14''. Paid for mushrooms on the full pizza and they only put mushrooms on half so, that was a bit of a disappointment, especially when a topping is over $3 for just a medium sized pizza... but, the pizza itself was good. It was thin, as a NY style pizza should be, sauce was good (but not great) and the cheese was very good. Mushrooms were good as well, they use fresh mushrooms not canned which, if you're a fan of mushrooms as a pizza topping, I'm sure you're aware of the difference. I wish I would have snapped a picture before digging in but, I was pretty hungry by the time it arrived.
K
Kerry A
2 contributions
18/04/24
• DoorDash order
We got the cheese and pepperoni pizza, and honey bbq wings. The wings were amazing, nice and saucy not too over cooked, basically just right. The pizza was also amazing, and the deal was Extra large 18" Cheese with 1 Topping & 20 wings for less than $70. Very happy, will be back.
J
Jo-Ann C
Emerging Expert • 16 contributions
5/04/25
• DoorDash order
The familiar taste of the Stuffed Shells with Red Sauce was so unbelievably good, that we actually called the restaurant to ask if they are "really from Brooklyn?" This dish is a literal bite out of Bensonhurst! Delicious! Mangia!!!
