“Many places claim to make Neapolitan pizza, but few go the extra mile to do it the right way. Elio Bartolotta takes a pretty old school approach to his pizza”. “Custom-made, wood-burning brick ove…
No joke, Elios is the best pizza I have ever had in my entire life, and this is coming from a die-hard deep dish lover. Remember when you were a kid watching cartoons, and the pizza in the cartoons would always look so much better than real life pizza? This is like that cartoon pizza - soft and even coating of fresh cheese that stretches for miles when you pull a slice from the pie, The perfect amount of the perfectly balanced sauce which isnt too sweet but isnt too acidic, and is the most amazing compliment to the flavorful, pillowy, and chewy dough and crust. Any toppings you get will just enhance the Elios experience and blow you away with how fresh and specialty they taste. I recommend you start with a pizza base that has toppings you already want on it, and then mix/match toppings to try different combos out and see what your favorites are. Mine is the Buffalina pizza with Prosciutto added on. The regular bacon pizza is also amazing and is probably my favorite pizza of all time. Thank you Elios!
J
Justin L
Local Expert • 95 contributions
4/12/23
• DoorDash review
Bacon pizza was pretty good, slightly too greasy but tasty. There are thick pieces of fatty bacon though which I am not a fan of, I prefer them thin and crispy. However, the real star of the show was the arancini! You get 3 large, almost baseball sized balls filled with risotto, delicious saucy meat, and a bit of peas. The only thing that could've made it better is a cup of marinara
E
Elio G
1 contributions
6/01/25
• DoorDash order
Absolutely delicious authentic Italian pizza. Found this place by chance, the photos, descriptions and the fact that I share the same name with the owner were all good signs, but I've been disappointed before, clearly not this time! as soon as the dasher opened up the trunk, the smell of that Capricciosa did hit me like a "Bentornato a casa". I'm a truck driver, I've been everywhere and this place just won every award in my book. my next pizza is going to be here or back home in Sicily.
K
Katarzyna C
6 contributions
3/08/24
• DoorDash order
As always, best pizza. Huge portion of Caesar Salad . Just don't recive any utensils for salad so small minus for that.
J
Jenna S
3 contributions
26/02/25
• DoorDash order
Hawaiian pizza was especially tasty, and the Nutella of course!
