There’s a lot of good pizza in New York City. Not all rise to the level of greatness, but the pies at Emmy Squared do. Part of the beloved Pizza Loves Emily mini-chain, Emmy Squared, serves (yes) squa…
Pizza, absolutely delicious. Basic ceasar salad for $13...should be $6. 4th star for the pizza.
S
Steph/Chris P
Local Expert • 31 contributions
11/05/25
• DoorDash review
I ordered an 8x10 gluten free tomato pie and got an anemic 6x8 piece of bread with 2 phalluses of red sauce. Truly, I wish I was joking. This (see photo) was $30 with tax and tip. Emmys is delusional regarding pie sizing and prices. Never again.
L
Lexy T
3 contributions
4/05/25
• DoorDash order
The food was delicious. However the order said it would be ready for pickup at 6:45pm and I waited outside for the food until 7:45pm. Staff were also not helpful.
M
Margaret D
3 contributions
12/02/25
• DoorDash order
My Make it Your Own pizza was tasty with the standard pizza toppings plus green pepper, red onion, and grilled chicken. Emmy's forgot my addition of mushrooms, but no biggie. The If Looks Could Kale salad was mostly yummy, but the champagne dressing was too earthy for my liking.
H
Horatio B
7 contributions
4/03/24
• DoorDash order
Great pizza but ittt bitty for $21 before tax and tip
