First we want to start saying we love Fat Paulies food it's delicious and reasonably priced! If you have never tried the Breakfast Barge it has to be a foot long, you need to it's my favorite thing on the menu! I have never measured it before but I should! Thank you!
D
David H
Local Expert • 58 contributions
6/05/25
• DoorDash order
Everything was great! The Hot Meatballs - Side were more meaty than my other favorite local place and close to taking first place, but I think someone accidentally put too much salt in the mix. Very salty but still great as was the sauce. Theb Side Salad ingredients very crisp and fresh, perfect size as side with meatballs for my lunch, delicious firm grape tomatoes. The Hero Roll was full size, enough to make a sub for two, and freshly soft. The House Roast Turkey per LB is good quality and packaged nicely. The Dried Cherry and Toasted Walnut Chicken Salad is nicely flavored and appetizing texture. Quality stuff and will continue to order here!
J
John R
Emerging Expert • 20 contributions
14/05/25
• DoorDash order
Outstanding sub, I ordered the BLTG with extra bacon, because most places don't use enough. This was ALMOST too much bacon, Almost. great sub, great fresh bread.. Best BLT I've ever had
C
Crystal F
Emerging Expert • 9 contributions
5/09/24
• DoorDash order
I wish I could give 4.5, but that's not an option.
Italian Mix was generously sized, the bread was great, and tasted perfect. I added sweet and hot sopressata, banana peppers and hot peppers definitely recommend
Meatball Parm was too big for 1 meal as well and meatballs were perfect, fresh mozzarella, and ordered extra sauce on side
Single Bagel pumpernickel bagels are hard to come by back home, so I had to get some for breakfast next day. it was a good choice
only tiny complaint, was not a fan of Sun-Dried Tomato Pesto Pasta SaladBacon and Scallion Potato Salad maybe it was an off day but both were dry and had a stale taste.
otherwise top notch joint
D
Dino J
Emerging Expert • 4 contributions
28/02/23
• DoorDash order
Excellent and consistent/reliable service! Their Michigan Cherry Salad is a favorite and their Chicken Parm Family Dinner is a plentiful serving with robust flavor. The only question I have is where do I find the Green Goddess dressing???
