Never thought that any ice cream flavor would beat my love for Bruster's Birthday Cake but I'd actually die for Handel's Cake Batter. My new favorite!!
N
Nichole A
4 contributions
19/06/25
• DoorDash review
I think I heard about this place on KDKA, so I decided to try it. Im an ice cream snob and am very picky about the quality of ice cream that I eat. This placeamazed me. I got a 4 scoop sampler, because I couldn't decide which flavor to try. I got my friends medum cup with vanilla and chocolate ice cream, fudge, peanut butter, and PB cups. the vanilla had a very clean taste with no artificial taste lingering in my mouth. The cookies were nice-sized pieces that I could really taste. Most surprisingly, the strawberry made me jump. Strawberry is one of my favorite flavors, and I have never tasted anything like this. it had a nice, smooth texture, it had a good, clean taste, and the strawberry punched me back. I could TASTE the strawberry like I just took a bite of one fresh off the vine. (It was so good that I ate a few bites and saved the rest for later, which I have literally never done before. I want to taste it by itself without the other flavors.) I am definitely ordering again!
B
Briauna H
1 contributions
24/04/24
• DoorDash order
Never mix in toppings when ordering a pint. Ordered coffee cookie dough chocolate chip and the cookie dough came on the side, and chocolate peanut butter, the peanut butter was in a cup on the side of a tub of chocolate ice cream. Instructions were given to mix in and they still dont. Ice cream is delicious and they used to mix the toppings in but something changed and it shouldnt have.
M
Maria M
19 contributions
8/02/25
• DoorDash review
Best Ice cream i've ever had hands down. Customer service, quality , pricing, portion sizes 10/10
J
Jen C
Emerging Expert • 9 contributions
17/10/21
• DoorDash review
My favorite local ice cream! Their flavors are delicious and consistent. Love the triple chocolate, the cake batter and the chocolate cake batter! Never disappoints! I would definitely recommend!
