Miss Molly's is an east coast Italian-inspired bakery offering a tasty array of unique items, including specialty cakes and desserts, calzones, and other savory items.
Please note that the DoorDash m…
"if people would only look to the cookie, all our problems would be solved." the Individual Pies banana cream flav filling had really nice flavor. Whoopie Pie was par for the perfectly manicured course. Black & White cookie was a tribute to June 29th, 1980. The cookie exuded unity and high contrast trickery by actually being frosted...on the bottom!?!??!~
R
R M
Local Expert • 89 contributions
11/06/24
• DoorDash order
Whoopie Pie was the star of the group for this second order. Individual Pies coconut flavor was pretty nice, slight freezer taste or something on the crust but not unbearable. the Carrot Cake was smaller than I expected, the flavor was right but also a slight freezer essence. the thing is that it's just not a $7 thing. $6 I might not have an opinion, $5 I'm feeling good about it. maybe I'm just used to massive slices of carrot cake but they also cost 7 bucks ish so I dunno where this is going. Individual Pies should have a Boston chocolate creampie option. that's all for now.
J
Jennifer R
2 contributions
7/07/24
• DoorDash order
The coconut cream individual pie was pretty tasty; though as mentioned in other reviews, not really worth the cost.
The butterscotch Italian Pasticiotti (Pusties) I could have done without. There was a hollowed out center & it was bland.
The German Chocolate cake was good but the coconut-pecan icing, though tasty, was a little grainy.
The Grandma's Molasses cookie was moist & delicious. I could eat a bunch of those.
The Peanut Butter (Gluten-Free) cookie was amazing! I could likewise eat a bunch of these.
We haven't tried the Cinn Rollamon yet so I may update later.
A
Anena L
36 contributions
5/05/24
• DoorDash review
The German chocolate cake was moist and flavorful. The carrot cake is just so-so. The pineapple flavor is nice, but it overwhelmed the carrots. I gave 2 stars because my breakfast calzone had pork in it. I specifically ordered the vegetable option. This means they need to be careful with labels on the foil. I gave the calzone away. I was really hungry too!
D
Darrel D
5 contributions
6/04/25
• DoorDash order
We've loved everything we've ever gotten here except for the chocolate chip cookies. It doesn't say on the menu but they are salted chocolate chip cookies. HUGE chunks of rock salt! Chipped one of my teeth and just didn't enjoy pockets of salt in my cookie. Would definitely continue to order from them but not the salted Chocolate Chip cookies!!
