Serving toasted sandwiches, pizza, salads, soups, and fresh baked cookies daily. Our locally owned and operated business serves the goodness of Pickleman's with fellow Hoosiers. We love catering to ou…
#11 Italian Club Sandwich was filledto the brim with meat and had flavor overload. I was stuffed after eating only one half of the sandwich.
S
Stephanie D
7 contributions
9/06/25
• DoorDash review
The food was delicious, but one of our sandwiches fell short. I ordered the Asiago Chicken sandwich, which had barely any chicken on it. I piled all the meat on one side of the sandwich, and I ended up throwing away the other half of the bread. Plus, the sandwiches were pretty small. I order out quite often and don't mind spending the money, but this order felt overpriced for what we got. I won't be ordering from this restaurant again.
K
Kristen H
6 contributions
10/02/25
• DoorDash order
This was my second order with Pickleman's. The first was good. This one was just off. I've been home sick, and tomato soup and grilled cheese sounded good. But, the tomato basil bisque had a layer or grease on top of it that I've never seen with tomato soup, and the grill cheese had no taste at all. Wouldn't order either again.
M
Melissa S
Local Expert • 40 contributions
11/11/24
• DoorDash order
Ive always had good food here, first time trying the BLT. Wasnt my favorite. Very little bacon and it was chewy, tasted like precooked bacon. Otherwise quality was on point with the bread and other ingredients & I finished the #13 B.L.T.C Sandwichwich
B
Brock W
18 contributions
2/12/24
• DoorDash order
#8 Cafe Club Sandwich was great for the price. The Chips were oily and flavorless.
