Puddletown Bagels offers 13 delicious flavors of New York style boiled bagels. Our bagels are free of additives and preservatives, boiled and baked daily. Our menu includes an assortment of signature …
Delicious Breakfast Bagel Sandwich! Probably the best value for greatest quality in town. Home Fries could have used some seasoning or salt, but they were good quality and the portion size was very generous. Would recommend!
A
Anna H
26 contributions
4/07/23
• DoorDash order
Good bagel but very tiny sausage and surprised for $8.25 no cheese is included (I guess you have to pay $0.75 for cheese). Just way overpriced. Cookie was so gross and stale (not just the texture but had that very old taste like its been there for a week or two). Sadly wont be back. If you only want bagels this place could be worth it.
C
Chris G
2 contributions
14/12/21
• DoorDash order
This is a great spot for awesome homemade bagel sandwiches. I order through DoorDash a lot and this is one of the few places that is quick & always gets my order right. The sandwich is huge and hearty. I order it for breakfast and finish it for lunch. My personal favorite is the cheddar jalapeño bagel with hummus, avocado, lettuce, tomato, onion and a slice of cheddar. Great job by Puddletown Bagels.
A
Allison W
3 contributions
5/01/23
• DoorDash order
Very disappointed in our breakfast. The smoked salmon bagel was absolutely disgusting, literally threw it away after a few bites and got one from Henry Higgins Bagels instead where we know it's good. The other bagel sandwiches we got were at least edible, but honestly not much more enjoyable. Bagels weren't even toasted. Definitely wouldn't order from here again.
L
Lindsey K
Local Expert • 55 contributions
17/10/24
• DoorDash order
The Breakfast Bagel Sandwich was inedible for me because I ordered it with sausage but they put bacon on it instead, and I do not like bacon at all. And the Home Fries came in a soup container wrapped in foil so the moisture got trapped inside and they were very soggy with Italian seasoning and zero salt. Really just not enjoyable at all. The three stars are literally because their bagels are excellent and I want them to stay in business so I can still have good bagels.
