WERE YOU AWARE?
Our dough is never sent frozen because it is produced fresh in-house.
Our mozzarella and cheddar cheeses are shred in-house using whole milk.
Our vegetables are hand-picked in the area…
Being from Long Island New York, I have high standards when it comes to food. Especially Pizza. This is the closest Pizza to a New York Pizza that I have found in this area in 17 years. I absolutely am in LOVE with Sgt. Peppers pizza.
L
Lori M
Emerging Expert • 13 contributions
19/10/24
• DoorDash order
both pizzas were delicious. Polynesian Pizza def my new favorite. couldn't really taste the onion on the other pizza since it was so thin.
Hot Honey was absolutely amazing but for a 1.20 for a little packet I'll go buy a bottle.
E
Elizabeth S
Emerging Expert • 6 contributions
15/06/25
• DoorDash order
Definitely the better pizza in the area (and that's comparing it to a lot in the tricities/Richmond area and coming from someone who has lived in places like SoCal and NY). Especially if you're looking for a New York style pizza. We got a cheese pizza for our littlest, who's our pickiest eater and she went back for seconds and even cleared that plate. My husband was happy to be able to add his favorite ingredients without being limited to just a few. My other kid and I just got a regular pepperoni. The family loved their pizza, but the only thing I didn't love about it was the fact that it seemed like the cheese and pepperoni were overcooked. I prefer that super melty, droopy pizza. This was more well-done (as you can see in the photos already on their menu). Sauce and dough were perfect, though.
T
Timothy B
2 contributions
13/02/25
• DoorDash order
the extra latge pizza is the same as the large pizza with an added cost. pizza was very flat and plain. would not recommend
J
Joshua R
5 contributions
21/12/24
• DoorDash review
I have high kudos for this establishment, not really for just the food but the SERVICE was fantastic and so thoughtful from the store. The DoorDash driver accidentally took the wrong order to me and one of the employees from Sgt Pepper's immediately called me and came with my correct order in mere minutes! Plus the pizza was delicious and reasonably priced, so we'll def order from them again many many times. Thank you Sgt Peppers!
