Slice of Brooklyn brings the unique flavors of Brooklyn to Central Jersey!
Our woodfired oven cooks up the best pizzas around, including our famous Old Fashioned Brooklyn pie! Sicilians, rounds, pers…
Big Ben combined the best of both worlds with this one! Can't decide between traditional and Sicilian? You don't have to! The crust was crunchy and pillowy. Fresh basil. Crispy small pepperoni. Great sauce. Highly recommend!!
M
Miles R
2 contributions
29/09/24
• DoorDash order
food quality is subpar! the Napolitano (Cheese Pizza) came with 4 slices of cheese pizza cold and soggy for $16 and looked nothing like the one in the photos. false advertisement!! Cheesesteak Sub bland no flavor and no seasoning.
S
Sarah C
Emerging Expert • 31 contributions
12/02/25
• DoorDash order
Old Fashion Brooklyn was tasty overall, but.... Sauce wasn't distributed well. Even though the dough is nice and yeasty, there was at least 4 inches of crust. Also not enough mozzarella or Romano cheese.
S
Sarah T
1 contributions
27/07/24
• DoorDash order
order my favorite chicken bacon ranch pizza which was amazing as always but we tried the mac and cheese in the bread bowl and omg was it amazing. best mac and cheese I have ever had and the bread bowl was so good too.
V
Vimal S
1 contributions
13/05/25
• DoorDash order
I placed a large order for my kids school and Slice of Brooklyn went above and beyond to ensure our needs were met and that it was delivered accurately. Their food is DELICIOUS and they have such good variety, which includes vegetarian options. Highly recommend!
