OMG, the food I ordered was exactly 💯 how I wanted it. I love Pizza Shack and from now on they're definitely going to be getting a lot of my business. The Pizza Sub with Mozzarella & Pepperoni Sub (Medium 8") was perfectly made absolutely delicious. the Wings (10 Pcs) were cooked to perfection and the did what my special instructions. Again if I could do more stars I would
T
Taylor H
1 contributions
26/09/22
• DoorDash order
The French Fries were okay, but very cold. The Garlic Knots (15 Pcs) are dry and practically inedible. The Potato Skins (5 Pcs) are very small and pretty dry, like they've been left out all night. My 20 Oz Bottle of Soda was also missing from my order. Very subpar for taking 45 minutes to cook everything. Very disappointing for how much the food costs. I would order from anywhere else before this place again.
C
Carrie M
4 contributions
19/05/24
• DoorDash order
best pizza. always loads of toppings. amazing crust. tasty sauce. never a bad pie!
D
DIANNE S
4 contributions
5/09/23
• DoorDash order
The Pizza Shack has the tastiest pizza ever! Orders are always correct, cooked as requested, pizza and wings are THE best in the Rochester area!
S
Steven B
Local Expert • 76 contributions
23/08/23
• DoorDash order
Both the Meatball with Mozzarella Sub (Large 12") and the Pizza Sub with Mozzarella & Pepperoni Sub (Large 12") were tasty, but lacked sauce so they were very dry. They also could have used more cheese, it that's all. They were cooked well, and not burnt.
