That was the best Chicken Roll i ever had. Chicken was crispy and crunchy but not dried out. The roll itself was tender and cheesy and seasoned. And i LOVE their Side of Marinara Sauce. Their sauce is a little sweet and a little tart. Love that. Hard to find a good, fresh chicken roll.
J
Jessica H
2 contributions
16/08/24
• DoorDash order
Used to love the Grandma Pie, ordered all the time. must have changed how they made it because it was all sauce, over abundance of dried herbs, barely any cheese and just tasted like garlic. The grease soaked through the box before it was even delivered. The Garlic Knots were overwhelming with the garlic taste.
C
Christine D
5 contributions
10/07/25
• DoorDash review
I tried something new and was not disappointed!! the summer chicken was flavorful! the portion was huge. nice and hot when it got here!! would order this again
D
diane w
1 contributions
8/10/24
• DoorDash order
Excellent pizza, including specialty pizza. They have greatly expanded their menu to include salads and numerous hot Italian meals. You will never be disappointed. The best Italian food in Suffolk County is finally here in Islip at affordable prices.
M
Michelle R
1 contributions
19/09/24
• DoorDash order
We are regulars at The Pizzeria, it's our favorite hands down. However when we received our order this time, the honey pep slice had been replaced with a Sicilian slice with pepperoni that looked like the pepperoni had not been heated all the way.
