Shelly Farren, Mike Aiello, and Jim Holland, longtime friends, decided to launch Shelly Pie on the spur of the moment.
The three of them make up the ownership that gives Shelly Pie its distinct style!…
Shlly is Pie is always a win! The pizza is cheesy and thecl crust is soft and chewy and delicious! The wings are flavorful and oh so good! I highly suggest their ranch and garlic dip/sauce. It's extra but it's delicious on wings, pizza, chicken tenders, everything!
G
Gretchen L
6 contributions
6/17/25
• DoorDash order
I ordered the medium 8-cut pie. It was the biggest medium pizza I have ever gotten, and it was delicious!!! Definitely worth the money. The pizza was LOADED with fresh mushrooms , pepperoni and black olives. I will definitely get this again.
E
Erica S
3 contributions
12/14/23
• DoorDash order
my fish was undercooked. my fries were undercooked and the butter had leaked to everything else. all my cheese and pepperoni slid to one side of the pizza it looked like a disaster. for 80 bucks I'm very disappointed
A
Ashton D
2 contributions
11/8/24
• DoorDash order
Oh. My. God. This is officially a new family favorite!!!! The Garlic Knots are SO GOOD!!!! The pizza is fantastic as well! I am so pleased with the quality and am very appreciative that they called to let me know one of the items was out instead of just replacing it with something I didn't want.
Italian Greens & Beans were good as well! Almost like my Nonis!
V
Virginia P
1 contributions
4/21/25
• DoorDash order
The food was excellent -- loved the beans and greens, and we shared the chicken parm and lasagna. Everything was perfect, and portions large. Garlic toast was nice as a side, and we topped it off with chocolate cake, which was delicious!
