The CLASSIC Benny Pepps is hands down, the best pizza in SLO. Absolutely, the most savory experience pizza provides the mouth. They put the sauce on top! I suspect the Detroit style of pizza sorcery they wield may have something to do with the awesomeness that is their pizza. don't forget to check their specials when you visit in person... they are unique to say the least.
D
Desiree A
2 contributions
3/24/25
• DoorDash order
Lasagna seemed soggy like the noodles were over cooked when assembling other than that it had good flavor. Kind of disappointing for the price though. Not my first time getting a lasagna from here so I know they are normally better. Pizza was delicious as always !!
S
Suzy M
1 contributions
6/7/22
• DoorDash review
OMG!!! This pizza is awesome! It is so thick, so tasty, and overflowing with yummy toppings. I love the soppresata - a new taste treat for me. Pizza and salad has always been my favorite meal, but now it's gotta be a Benny's pizza and salad.
Z
Zack S
Emerging Expert • 24 contributions
11/14/24
• DoorDash order
Really enjoyed the first time I ordered here, and thought it might be worth the price on a special occasion. But the second time ordering the pizza was very over cooked, to the point that it was too hard to bite through, and burnt to charcoal in some places. Can't afford to pay very high prices without consistency of very high quality.
R
Ryan P
2 contributions
6/17/22
• DoorDash order
Great flavor in the sauce with a slight kick. . Perfect balance of crust, cheese, sauce, and toppings. My go to pizza spot in slo.
