There’s a lot of good pizza in New York City. Not all rise to the level of greatness, but the pies at Emmy Squared do. Part of the beloved Pizza Loves Emily mini-chain, Emmy Squared, serves (yes) squa…
Pudding is huge. Taste not overly sweet but sweetness is on point. Chunks of bananas in it! Amazing.
Being from NY, I am a pizza snob. And this pizza is on point just as good if not better then back home. Best pizza in Philly! Hands down!
Hidden but now found restaurant! Amazing!
S
Steph P
Local Expert • 31 contributions
5/11/25
• DoorDash review
I ordered an 8x10 gluten free tomato pie and got an anemic 6x8 piece of bread with 2 phalluses of red sauce. Truly, I wish I was joking. This (see photo) was $30 with tax and tip. Emmys is delusional regarding pie sizing and prices. Never again.
S
Shahzad I
Local Expert • 31 contributions
3/23/24
• DoorDash order
Got the Colony pizza without pickled jalapeños and it was amazing. Regardless of Detroit style vs NY style, Emmy's pizzas are great in taste, flavor, and texture. They also come with the perfect and simple reheating instructions on the box itself.
Secondly, I got the Cheesy Garlic Sticks and they are amazing by itself in my opinion (don't need the marinara/tomato sauce on the side). Just like the pizza this can also be reheated for 3-4 minutes at 450F.
Lastly, I got the Brussels Sprouts Salad without the red pickled onions and dried cherries, and I asked for a portion of the crispy chicken. The salad was good but the crispy chicken was made so well that it should be a menu item on its own.
A
Aaliyah F
1 contributions
9/21/23
• DoorDash order
Pizzas are very small and not worth $20 a pie. The Chicken Parm Sandwich was ok . If you're looking for a quick small bite to eat this is for you, but the pizza is personal size so you will have to order multiple
B
Brian D
Emerging Expert • 10 contributions
4/29/24
• DoorDash order
Ordered the classic with pepperoni. The pizza was fantastic. Great taste, nice crunch. It is just crazy they charge so much for a pizza so small. It is really a 5-star taste but nearly $30 for 6 small-ish square pieces of pizza is criminal. If they either made their pizzas larger or charged like $12 a pizza, I would order from here every night of the week. Took off two stars bc of the price alone. Shame because it's great pizza but to feed a family you would need to order like 5 of these things and spend over $150 on pizza which at that point just go to a restaurant. That said, if money is no object, order from here and get a delicious pizza. Took a bite before taking the pic.
