We serve authentic New York-style pizza.
All of our items are created fresh daily in our kitchen, including our dough, sauces, and dressings. We use organic, local fruit and shredded mozzarella cheese…
THE BEST PIZZA SERIOUSLY- Fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection its also light and not greasy the large size is decent for 2 but its so good you would want more. I has Large Specialty Pizza Half & Half the truffle and the hawaiian and am gonna order more. The Dipping sauces are delish n fresh!
R
Rachel P
Local Expert • 48 contributions
1/6/24
• DoorDash order
This place is a gem! I'm from NYC so I'm a bit of a pizza snob and knew not to expect what you'd find in Morris Park or Bay Ridge. But Fat Tomato is truly just a class of its own. I was so curious to try the Korean sweet potato pizza so I got Large Specialty Pizza Half & Half so I wouldn't have to commit to a whole pie, this option is great if you want to try something new but still have some safety plain pizza! It was delicious and unlike anything else I'd ever had. Mozzarella sticks are baked so they're not as greasy and dense as your usual mozzy sticks. Will definitely order from again.
K
Katherine M
7 contributions
5/28/25
• DoorDash order
This is one of the BEST Creat your own Gluten Free 12" Medium NY Cheese Pizza (Build Your Own) 6 slices I have ever had!!! The cheese is out of this world!
P
Prosy D
Local Expert • 100 contributions
6/19/24
• DoorDash order
Excellent flavors, not greasy and you taste the meats and the fresh vegetables- good crust also. You get value for your dollars, as if homemade in my house. I truly love the name- its pizza deserves it!
B
Bonnie T
Emerging Expert • 10 contributions
11/23/23
• DoorDash order
This $20-$30 pizza tastes like one notch above a boxed frozen pizza. Not bad just more like great for late night if u don't want to go out. Otherwise save yourself the $ and grab a $7-$10 at the grocery store. Ranch tastes like out of the bottle.
