For nearly 40 years, Fierro's has served as East Hampton's village pizzeria. Fierro's continues to develop and provide a warm greeting and a delicious slice to the neighborhood all year long, thanks t…
Best pizza. The plain cheese is a classic. So flavorful, I love the sauce. Perfect. Cannoli's are excellent too.
C
Christina A
1 contributions
4/6/23
• DoorDash order
The Caesar salad was very small for almost $25. The entire container of lettuce is brown. Literally three strips or chicken that is so hard I couldn't chew it. Threw it all away. Disappointing
L
Laura C
17 contributions
1/17/23
• DoorDash order
I regularly order from Fierro's. However, I'm surprised at the slice of cake being $8, and dry at that. Salads are additionally costly & small.
E
Elisa B
1 contributions
4/28/25
• DoorDash order
The description of the vegetarian pizza on rhe menu says no cheese . The pizza was covered with cheese. I had to pick it off ! For almost 36 dollars for a small pie I would exp better! Even the cheese pizza we ordered was dry cold and tasteless. Forget this place!
J
James O
5 contributions
6/13/22
• DoorDash order
I may have gotten the wrong order or they did made the margarita wrong (it was a regular white cheese pizza with tomato slices instead of the mozzarella slices and basil it's supposed to be). Besides that the regular cheese pizza, onion rings and fries were pretty average (nothing special compared to other places for the same price).
