the 18" Sword was great . it was prepared and ready on time/ fast. I swapped the chicken for ham so that it was what is often called a Hawaiian pizza. The only thing is that there was not as much pineapple as I would have liked. I ordered the thin crust. it was excellent. shared with a friend and she also loved it ( but also wished there was more pineapple). we will ask for extra pineapple next time.
J
Joshua G
1 contributions
7/22/24
• DoorDash order
toppings of pizza just clumped together some areas was just cheese. the were stingy on the meat but loaded the peppercini. garlic knots had hit of cinnamon which was off putting. pizza was soggy maybe undercooked. Just bad experience overall for a first experience. $30 dollars in food wasted
J
Jonathan W
6 contributions
2/11/23
• DoorDash order
I order the Chicken Caesar Sub at least three times a week and love it this is the first time I was truly disappointed the bread was burnt there was barely any Caesar dressing on the sub and there were max four strips of chicken on it it was the saddest Chicken Caesar sub I've seen I took two bites and threw it in the garbage. It's upsetting because by the time all fees are included it was $19 and change. I would have been better off lighting a $20 bill on fire not to mention I ordered two slices of pizza which I didn't include in the $19 and change, each slice cost an additional $2.99. I've heard people say you have the best pizza in Tallahassee since every time I've ordered from Gaines Street I get the Chicken Caesar sub and it's been out of this world every time except this last experience I figured I would try the pizza since I've heard people say it so good. I don't know if I got a pizza that was rushed or what the deal was but there was no consistency in the crust it went from being thin as a cracker it literally made crackle snap noise as soon as I took the first bite I thought I cracked my tooth. Once I got past the parts that were unnecessarily thin crispy, that were actually a normal thin pizza crust consistency we're good if only whoever stretched that dough or rolled it out consistently normally thin it would have been a really good pizza!! I hope when I order again in the next few days that the kitchen is back to normal or otherwise I will not be spending my hard-earned money at Gaines Street pies anymore.
J
Jonathan W
6 contributions
2/10/23
• DoorDash order
The chicken caesar sub is out of this world!! The bread is perfectly soft but warm and the chicken is not overcooked at all it's cooked to perfection!! I eat this sandwich at least twice a week for dinner!!
J
Jay G
Local Expert • 132 contributions
4/18/23
• DoorDash order
Everything was good but the hummus appetizer could stand to be larger for what I paid, not worth the price.
